Free calculator · no signup
Is switching to Notion actually worth it?
The subscription gap is the easy part. This counts the rest: the template, your setup time, the hours you will spend maintaining it, and the tools you will still need next to Notion. Then it tells you the payback, or that there is none.
Extra cost over 3 years
$5,913
Staying costs $9,612; switching costs $15,525 including $2,349 of one-time setup.
This counts money and your time. It does not count the features you would lose, the risk of a migration, or vendor support. Read should you leave your practice software?, can Notion replace Clio? and the software cost calculator.
How the calculation works
- Current monthly cost = users × price per user + monthly add-ons.
- Notion running cost per month = users × Notion price + tools you still need + maintenance hours × value of an hour.
- One-time cost = template + setup hours × value of an hour.
- Total if you stay = current monthly cost × months.
- Total if you switch = Notion running cost × months + one-time cost.
- Saving = total if you stay − total if you switch.
- Payback = one-time cost ÷ (current monthly cost − Notion running cost per month), shown only when the monthly saving is positive.
Two worked examples
Three users, $89 each, switching to Notion Plus at $12. Current: 3 × $89 = $267 a month. Notion running: 3 × $12 + $30 (a trust tool) + 2 hours × $150 = $366 a month. The monthly saving is negative, so there is no payback: with your time valued at $150 an hour, staying is cheaper.
Ten users, $89 each. Current: $890 a month. Notion running: 10 × $12 + $30 + $300 = $450 a month. Saving: $440 a month. One-time cost: $99 + 15 × $150 = $2,349. Payback: about 5.3 months, and over three years a saving of roughly $13,500.
The same lawyer, valuing their time at zero, would see a positive result in both cases. That is why the value of an hour is an input.
How to read the result
- Strong saving, short payback (under a year): the numbers favour switching; now weigh the risks and features.
- Small saving, long payback: the numbers are neutral; decide on fit.
- No payback: cost is not the reason to switch; consider a hybrid or a cheaper tier.
What the numbers do not capture
- Integrated trust accounting, payments and court rules you would lose.
- The risk of errors during migration, especially deadlines.
- Vendor support and the cost of being your own help desk.
- The upside: flexibility, a firm knowledge base, ownership of your system.
Frequently asked questions
Is switching from Clio or MyCase to Notion worth it?
It depends on how many users you have, what you pay now, which tools you would still need beside Notion, and what your time is worth. For three or more seats the subscription saving often outweighs setup and maintenance; for a solo it may save cash but not time. This calculator counts all of it and tells you the payback, or that there is none.
What does the payback figure mean?
The number of months until the one-time cost of switching (a template and your setup hours) is recovered by the monthly saving. If the new setup costs as much or more each month than the old one, there is no payback.
Why does the calculator count my time?
Because unpaid hours are still a cost. Setting up and maintaining a system takes hours you could spend on billable work or rest. You can set the value of an hour to zero if you want a cash-only view.
What tools might I still need beside Notion?
Usually trust accounting software (Notion cannot hold the ledger), a billing and payments tool, an e-signature service and a rules-based calendaring service if you litigate. Enter their monthly cost in the 'tools you still need' field.
What do the default numbers mean?
They are illustrative: three users, a mid-tier practice-management price, Notion Plus, a $99 template, 15 setup hours, two maintenance hours a month and $150 for an hour of your time. Replace them with your own quotes.
What does this calculator not include?
The features you would lose, the risk of a migration, vendor support, and the benefit of better flexibility or knowledge management. It counts money and time only.
Where do I get accurate prices?
From the vendors' current pricing pages and quotes. Practice-management software typically costs roughly $40 to $150 per user per month depending on tier, and Notion Plus about $10 to $12 per seat. Check both before you decide.
Is a negative result a reason not to switch?
Not necessarily: you may switch for fit, flexibility or ownership. But it is a reason to be clear that cost is not the argument, and to consider a hybrid or a cheaper tier first.
Related: can Notion replace Clio?, should you leave your practice software?, migrating from Clio to Notion and the four-way comparison.