The rules, mapped to practical duties
| Rule | Topic | What it means in practice |
|---|---|---|
| 1.1 | Competence | Understand the benefits and risks of the technology you use |
| 1.4 | Communication | Tell clients what they need to make informed decisions |
| 1.5 | Fees | Charge reasonable fees; do not bill for time you did not spend |
| 1.6 | Confidentiality | Make reasonable efforts to prevent unauthorised disclosure |
| 3.3 | Candour to the tribunal | Do not submit false authorities; check AI citations |
| 5.1 / 5.3 | Supervision | Supervise lawyers and non-lawyers, including vendors, with reasonable measures |
What Formal Opinion 512 covers
ABA Formal Opinion 512, issued in July 2024, was the ABA's first formal opinion on generative AI. It discusses competence, confidentiality, communication, candour, supervision and fees. Commentary highlights that entering client information into some AI tools raises confidentiality concerns and may require the client's informed consent, and that generic boilerplate in an engagement letter is unlikely to be enough. Read the opinion itself, since summaries differ on the details.
From rules to routine
- 1
Choose
Assess the vendor: security attestations, data location, terms on training and retention.
- 2
Configure
Limit access, disable public sharing and apply least privilege.
- 3
Tell
Where needed, explain to clients how tools are used and obtain informed consent.
- 4
Verify
Check every AI-generated citation and fact before using it.
- 5
Supervise
Train staff and keep a written policy.
Frequently asked questions
- Is ABA Formal Opinion 512 binding?
- No. ABA opinions are persuasive guidance. Binding rules are those adopted in your jurisdiction, though state bars often follow the ABA's reasoning.
- Do the Model Rules allow cloud storage?
- ABA guidance has long accepted cloud services where the lawyer exercises reasonable care in selecting and using them.
- Does Rule 1.1 require me to use AI?
- No. It asks for competence, which includes understanding the technology you do use. Whether to use AI is a professional decision.
- Where are the rules published?
- The ABA publishes the Model Rules and its formal opinions on americanbar.org; your state bar publishes its own versions.
About the author
Raghav Handa trained as a lawyer, then spent years building legal technology, from enterprise legal products to custom systems for law firms.
Keep reading
- Security and ethicsFirm AI policy template for lawyers (fill-in outline)A fill-in outline for a law firm AI use policy: scope, approved tools, confidentiality, verification, client disclosure, training and review. General guidance only.3 min read · 17 October 2026
- Rules and regulationClient consent for AI use: template wording and outlineA fill-in outline for telling clients about AI use and recording informed consent: what to explain, options to offer, and how to log it. General guidance.3 min read · 17 October 2026
- Security and ethicsAI ethics for lawyers: a short working guideA short working guide to AI ethics for lawyers: the questions to ask before using any AI tool on client work, and where to find the rules for your jurisdiction.3 min read · 17 October 2026
- Security and ethicsIs Notion secure enough for lawyers? Confidentiality, ethics and setupIs Notion safe for client data? Its certifications and encryption, the ABA's reasonable-efforts standard, the real risks and how to configure it.4 min read · 17 October 2026